Prefer a printed copy?
Request a complimentary copy from LeftCoast and HST while supplies last.
A common point of failure in ambulatory surgery planning is allowing a facility, partner, or transaction to define the strategy. The stronger approach is to begin with the health system’s strategic objective and define the role ambulatory surgery should play across the broader care delivery network. Once that role is established, decisions related to partnerships, operating models, technology, and capital deployment can be made with greater discipline and consistency. In this way, strategy becomes the north star that aligns investments and actions with enterprise objectives.
INSIDE THIS GUIDE
Executive summary
The migration of outpatient surgery is reshaping where and how health systems deliver surgical care, driven by shifting reimbursement policy, physician demand for equity ownership, payer pressure toward lower-cost sites, clinical advancements, over-capacity in hospital ORs, and tightening margins. Hospital outpatient departments (HOPDs) and ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) often look similar clinically but differ substantially in legal structure, licensure, and billing. Outpatient surgery is also very different from other ambulatory services, such as imaging, urgent care, and clinics. Understanding these distinctions is the starting point for a credible site-of-care strategy.
Building an effective ambulatory surgery strategy requires clear alignment on the health system’s overarching objectives and an understanding of how outpatient surgery fits within its broader care delivery network. Decisions about new development, partnerships, and ownership cannot be evaluated in isolation; they must account for the impact on hospital operations, physician alignment, patient access, and enterprise-wide financial performance. With these objectives established, health systems can develop a coordinated approach to site-of-care and ownership, translate that strategy into local execution, align financial and technology infrastructure to the operating model, and establish consistent measures of success. Ultimately, successful execution depends on rigorous market analysis, strong physician engagement, effective governance, and organizational commitment to carrying out the strategy.
THE FRAMEWORK AT A GLANCE
Define the problem you are trying to solve
Establish an enterprise-wide ambulatory surgery strategy
Translate enterprise strategy into local market execution
Model your financial and technology architecture
Create a data-driven feedback loop
Background
To respond effectively, health system leaders must first understand how outpatient surgical settings differ in legal structure, licensure, and billing, then understand the trends reshaping where surgical care is delivered.
Understand surgery location definitions and sites of care
Before examining site-of-care strategy, it is important to establish common definitions. While HOPDs and ASCs often deliver similar clinical services, their legal and financial structures differ considerably. Understanding these differences is critical to evaluating the opportunities and challenges associated with outpatient surgery. For the purposes of this paper, outpatient surgery is defined as procedures performed in HOPDs and ASCs.
| Distinction | Inpatient hospital | HOPD | ASC | Office-based surgery (OBS) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Legal entity and ownership | Hospital entity, typically nonprofit but potentially for-profit; often part of a larger health system. | A department of a hospital that provides same-day discharge surgery. Owned by the hospital. Care provided as part of all other hospital services. | A distinct legal entity, separate from a hospital. Typically a for-profit entity. Owners may include a health system, medical group, individual physicians, an ASC management company, or a combo. | Typically operated by a physician, group practice, or other entity separate from the hospital and ASC; the legal and tax structure varies. |
| Licensure and regulatory context | Hospital licensure and Medicare Conditions of Participation; CMS POS 21 | Hospital licensure and provider-based requirements; CMS POS 22 on campus and POS 19 off campus | State facility licensure, accreditation or certification, Medicare ASC Conditions for Coverage; ASC certification guidance; CMS POS 24 | Office-based surgery facilities are not licensed by the state and are treated the same as a clinic. State oversight comes through licensing of the physicians and anesthesia use; CMS POS 11 may apply |
| Acuity and discharge expectations | Higher acuity, multiple day lengths of stay. | Moderate acuity, 0-3 day length of stay. | Moderate acuity, same-day discharge. | Lower acuity, same-day discharge, limited anesthesia needs. |
| How cases are billed | Medicare pays one MS-DRG amount per discharge under IPPS; professional services billed separately. | Hospital bills facility services under OPPS (APC/ |
ASC bills a facility fee; most facility services and supplies are packaged in. Surgeon/ |
Physician bills professional services, including a larger technical component. No ASC payment applies. |
Recognize trends accelerating the push to ambulatory surgery in health systems
Several factors are driving more procedures into outpatient settings. Although these trends are important considerations for health system leaders, they should inform rather than drive strategy, which must ultimately be grounded in organizational objectives, market conditions, and patient needs.
Medicare policy is expanding ASC eligibility.
CMS continues to greatly expand the procedures eligible for ASC reimbursement, accelerating the migration of appropriate surgical cases to outpatient settings.
Physicians increasingly see ASCs as attractive when equity ownership and operational control are available.
Equity ownership and operational control can be powerful tools for physician recruitment, retention, and alignment with operational changes, while employed physicians may place greater value on efficiency, productivity, scheduling reliability, and clinical experience.
Hospital operating rooms are over capacity and out of date.
Under-investment in facilities over many years has resulted in OR platforms that are not aligned with the hospital’s or community’s needs. Upgrades or expansions are extremely costly, especially in older facilities. The idea of shifting cases to new, current spaces can be appealing to health system leaders.
Site neutrality is no longer just a future risk; it has partly arrived.
CMS’s CY2026 rule already pays some hospital outpatient services at site-neutral rates. Continued movement in this direction could further erode the financial viability of hospital-based surgical care.
Payers want clinically appropriate procedures performed at lower-cost sites.
Payers increasingly encourage procedures to be performed in the lowest-cost clinically appropriate setting to reduce healthcare spending.
Health system margins are under pressure as reimbursement stagnates and costs rise.
Rising labor, supply, pharmaceutical, and regulatory costs are increasing pressure on health systems to improve health-system-wide profitability.
Taken together, these trends should make site-of-care strategy a top health system priority.
5 critical elements for an effective outpatient surgery strategy
Successful ambulatory surgery strategies are built intentionally, not opportunistically. Health systems that achieve the greatest value from outpatient surgery start with a clear strategic objective and then build everything around that objective. This framework highlights the critical decisions that should guide the development of an effective outpatient surgery strategy.
STEP 1
Define the problem you are trying to solve
Every ambulatory strategy should begin with a clear understanding of the problem the organization is trying to address.
Typical primary drivers include:
- Market-share growth and capacity expansion
- Financial improvement and margin enhancement
- Physician alignment, recruitment, and retention
Secondary goals may include volume retention, improved access, payer positioning, referral capture, service-line defense, network resiliency, and missional alignment. While multiple objectives may exist, one primary objective should guide decision-making and capital allocation.
KEY QUESTION
What problem are we trying to solve, and how will we measure success?
Before approving an opportunity, an executive should be able to complete this sentence: We are pursuing this ASC strategy primarily to , and we will know it is working when . If that sentence cannot be completed with measurable terms, the organization is not ready to scale its ASC strategy.
STEP 2
Establish an enterprise-wide ambulatory surgery strategy
Once the primary driver is determined, then develop your enterprise strategy around it. Without an enterprise framework, organizations risk developing individual centers that appear successful locally but fail to generate system-level value. There are two key components: 1) the site-of-care strategy, and 2) the management, ownership, and governance strategy.
Site-of-care strategy
A site-of-care strategy identifies which procedures belong in which settings, what capacity is available or constrained, and how patients and physicians move through the network. Determine:
- Which procedures belong in each setting and why
- Existing and future capacity needs
- Sources of volume growth and leakage
- Patient and physician geography and commuting needs
- Impact of case migration on hospitals and other facilities
Ownership, partnership, and governance strategy
This strategy determines who owns, operates, and controls decision-making for each ASC. Determine:
- Whether ASCs should be wholly owned, jointly owned with physicians, and/or partial ownership with an ASC management company
- Whether ASCs will be acquisitions, de novo builds, HOPD-to-ASC conversions, and/or a lease or “use it” arrangement for OR time in an existing ASC
- Governance, decision rights, and accountability structures
KEY QUESTION
What role should ambulatory surgery, especially ASCs, play in the broader health system strategy?
A large medical group and a multi-state health system partnered to develop a joint venture ambulatory surgery center (ASC) as part of their growth strategies. There were two issues that emerged: 1) competing priorities of facility strategies (IP/HOPD vs. ASC) and 2) physician alignment differences between invested and non-invested physicians.
On the facility side, both partners relied on the same core group of surgeons to drive volume across the hospital and the ASC, creating competition for cases rather than alignment. Differing economic incentives created tension around case migration and growth expectations. On the physician side, invested and non-invested physicians were treated differently, creating medical staff friction and limiting broader engagement. Each group had a distinct value proposition, and the venture did not weigh them deliberately.
Project delays, elevated operating expenses, and slower-than-expected volume delayed profitability and intensified both issues, while governance limitations added further risk.
Takeaways: First, health systems must evaluate where volume is coming from and going to before developing an ambulatory strategy. Second, invested and non-invested physicians each have a different value proposition. Where both want access to an ASC-type model, design for each deliberately rather than assuming one structure serves both.
STEP 3
Translate enterprise strategy into local market execution
An enterprise strategy creates direction, but success also depends on effective local implementation.
Each center should evaluate:
- Market and physician demand
- Competitive dynamics
- Capacity constraints
- Referral patterns
- Facility location
- Operational feasibility
Most importantly, physicians should be involved early on before major investments occur. Migration is surgeon-dependent, not simply case- or hospital-dependent.
Do not ask only, “How many cases could move?” Ask, “Which physicians will move which cases, why will they move them, and what will they have to change?”
KEY QUESTION
Will the physicians who generate volume actually use the proposed solution?
A health system in the Western US was evaluating potential locations for a new ASC. The initial market analysis focused on traditional demand indicators, including patient ZIP code distribution, population growth, projected case volumes, and patient travel patterns. This analysis suggested that the proposed location would be highly convenient for patients and capable of supporting the expected procedural volume. However, while the approach identified an area with strong patient demand, it did not address a critical question: would the surgeons responsible for generating that volume be willing and able to move their cases to the new facility?
Because ASC utilization is heavily influenced by surgeon behavior, it was recommended to the organization that they expand their analysis to include surgeon home ZIP code mapping. This revealed that many of the surgeons expected to generate the majority of surgical volume were located farther from the proposed site. For several of these physicians, the proposed location would increase travel time, create workflow inefficiencies, and contribute to more fragmented schedules.
By incorporating surgeon geography into the site selection process, the health system gained a more realistic understanding of the physician adoption risk. The findings highlighted an important consideration not apparent from patient demand analysis alone: projected utilization depends not only on where patients live, but also on whether physicians are willing to shift their cases.
Takeaway: When evaluating potential locations, look beyond simple market demand and include analysis of patient access, physician satisfaction, and operational feasibility. This broader perspective helps create a location strategy that is both achievable and sustainable over the long term.
STEP 4
Model your financial and technology architecture
A well-chosen site and a willing physician base are necessary conditions for success, but they are only pieces of a larger puzzle. The financial and technology architecture underlying each ASC determines whether that local execution actually delivers the profitability and efficiency the enterprise strategy set out to achieve.
Financial architecture
Organizations should evaluate:
- Enterprise-level economics, e.g., the incremental effect on revenue, contribution margin, and EBITDA for the health system
- Facility-level economics, e.g., a center-specific pro forma
- Case-level profitability, e.g., granular case modeling
The most successful organizations understand not only whether an ASC will be profitable, but also how case migration affects the broader health system.
Technology architecture
Technology decisions should support the operating model rather than dictate it. The objective is to:
- Enable efficient ASC workflows across scheduling, billing, inventory management, and surgical charting
- Maximize reimbursement per case billed
- Provide actionable operational, financial, and clinical reporting
- Preserve continuity of care and data for patients and physicians
There are two common approaches for ambulatory surgery:
Use the Enterprise EHR only (in the Hospital & Ambulatory Surgery)
PROS
- Continuity of patient chart
- Familiarity of physician tool
- More simplified tech stack, single vendor
- No interface risk
CONS
- Not optimized for ASC workflows; less efficient
- Lengthy implementation process at the center
- Lower ASC staff satisfaction due to cumbersome and manual workflows
- Doesn’t compute ASC billing and time-consuming to manage denials
- Lots of documentation required for each ASC case
- More costly
- Lacks automated ASC reporting across individual ASC and portfolio view of ASCs
Use ASC-specific software connected to the Enterprise EHR
PROS
- Cost effective
- Best of breed software by use case
- Improved financial performance
- Higher staff satisfaction
- More efficient workflows
- Faster surgical charting
- Automated ASC reporting across individual ASC and portfolio view of ASCs
- Out of the box case costing
CONS
- Manage multiple software vendors and processes
- Initial interface implementation required
- Manage interface between systems
- Sync gaps if interface breaks
- Lack of enterprise messaging
One key distinction to keep in mind: CMS treats HOPDs and ASCs differently. An HOPD is part of the hospital, so sharing the hospital’s medical record system makes sense. An ASC is a separate legal entity with its own CMS requirements, including the obligation to maintain its own complete and accurate medical records.
As a result, using the hospital’s EHR at an ASC needs careful thought. Full record ownership, access, and information sharing between the two organizations can all raise compliance and privacy questions. Enterprise technology can still work for an ASC, but it should be a deliberate choice rather than an assumption.
KEY QUESTION
Does the financial and technology architecture enable ASCs to meet profitability expectations and operate with efficient workflows?
STEP 5
Create a data-driven feedback loop
An ambulatory surgery network cannot be effectively managed without consistent performance measurement.
Organizations should develop a common set of metrics that allows leaders to assess areas such as:
- Performance against the primary driver from Step 1
- Financial performance
- Case volume and mix
- OR capacity utilization
- Physician engagement
- Quality and patient experience
Data should support both operational decisions and strategic oversight, creating a continuous feedback loop that informs future investment and expansion decisions.
KEY QUESTION
Do we have the data needed to measure performance? Can we easily and repeatedly access, track, and compare performance to make timely decisions?
CONCLUSION
Build an integrated site-of-care network
The strongest health system ambulatory surgery strategies are not really about ASCs alone. Success requires understanding which procedures belong in which sites of care, aligning physicians around those care settings, evaluating both center-level and system-level economics, and operating ASCs with efficiency and discipline.
Just as important, there is no single blueprint for ASC development. Health systems can pursue a variety of ownership, governance, and management structures. Rather than starting with a facility, organizations should begin by asking a simple question: What problem are we trying to solve? That objective should drive the strategy, not specific facility opportunities.
When approached in this manner, an ASC investment or joint venture becomes more than a standalone facility or financial transaction. It becomes an integrated platform for expanding outpatient surgical access, strengthening physician alignment, supporting disciplined capital investment, and enabling sustainable health system growth in an increasingly outpatient-focused healthcare environment.
About the co-authors
LeftCoast Healthcare Advisors
LeftCoast Healthcare Advisors is a team of healthcare advisors with a focus on ambulatory surgery. Their team of experienced operators is committed to driving real change in the way healthcare is delivered in communities.
HST Pathways
HST is an all-in-one software platform built specifically for ASCs to run their daily operations like scheduling, billing, charting, inventory management, and more. It is trusted by more than 2,000 ASCs and 75,000 users across the US and Canada, with more than 50 million cases documented on its platform.


